Privacy: A Two Way Street With Two-Way Mirrors Betwixt

Part one of a two part series.

I was reading my Sunday paper yesterday (on the day it arrived- a triumph of slackdom over obligation) and I noticed a blurb mentioning a new Virginia law that took effect on July 1. The law requires all of Virginia’s public and private universities and colleges to submit names and social security numbers of their students to the state police so that they can be checked aginst sex offender registries. [Wash. Post 06-06-20] While I understand the basis for the provision- keep the sexual predators out of the dorms-it opens up doors to wide ranges of abuse and general failures in personal privacy.

Even if the state uses the information only as intended and makes an effort to purge the data in a regular cycle, the increasing rate of data theft raises serious flags. Whose credit is riper for the picking than a college student, fresh out of high school with the new credit card mom and dad co-signed for so he/she could establish credit (read: debt) and learn responsibility (read: buy kegs)?

The good news, as pointed out by Mike Stollenwerk, Chairman of the Fairfax County [Virginia] Privacy Council (Yes, the FCPC website is laughable, but Mr. Stollenwerk is no stranger to this sort of case), is that the Federal Privacy Act of 1974 applies:

DISCLOSURE OF SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER

Section 7 of Pub. L. 93-579 provided that:
‘(a)(1) It shall be unlawful for any Federal, State or local
government agency to deny to any individual any right,
benefit, or privilege provided by law because of such
individual’s refusal to disclose his social security account
number.
‘(2) the (The) provisions of paragraph (1) of this subsection
shall not apply with respect to –
‘(A) any disclosure which is required by Federal statute, or
‘(B) the disclosure of a social security number to any Federal,
State, or local agency maintaining a system of records in
existence and operating before January 1, 1975, if such
disclosure was required under statute or regulation adopted
prior to such date to verify the identity of an individual.
‘(b) Any Federal, State, or local government agency which
requests an individual to disclose his social security account
number shall inform that individual whether that disclosure is
mandatory or voluntary, by what statutory or other authority
such number is solicited, and what uses will be made of it.’

What this means is that, apart from federal laws which cite themselves as exceptions (one such provision was written to allow Motor Vehicle Departments to use SSN’s, the IRS is another exception,) no agency or organization may require your Social Security Number in order to transact business or provide services. It also states that if they do ask for your SSN, they need to make it clear that it’s use is either mandatory or voluntary and why. Colleges and universities in Virginia do not operate under any federal mandate to track Social Security Numbers. Applicants should be made aware that they do not have to submit their number and they should opt against.

More tomorrow before I fire up the grill.

It’s A Long Long Long Long Way To Go Home…

R.I.P. – Vince Welnick

It pains me to follow my last post with this news but, Grateful Dead keyboard player Vince Welnick has died. The circumstances are not confirmed but it’s a sad day. Vince played keys at every Grateful Dead show that attended. There were plenty who didn’t get doen with what he was doing and I’ve downed him some myself but, as far as I’m concerned, Vince was and forever shall be one of The Grateful Dead. That makes him family.

He’ll be missed.

Much love to his wife, Lori and to all who loved Vince.

SF Gate Coverage here.
AOL News Item
CNN Article (with his age incorrectly reported.)

Let me add the following link with a caveat. Some people don’t like to hear bad things about people. This link does not put some people in the best light but I happen to believe what the post has to say. It is sad that when the Other remaining Grateful Dead members billed shows as “all of the surviving Grateful Dead members” they had the balls not to invite Vince. Jerry said he was a full member and thats enough for me.

Vince Welnick.com

Time Keeps On Slipping…


All right, I’ll admit it. We forgot about Daylight Saving Time starting today and, because of that, my wife and eldest daughter were late to serve as tools of the vast Girl Scout Cookie Empire.

Spring forward.

Fall back.

blah blah blah.

Of course, they tell us that the whole thing is designed to save energy but, does it? The answers seem to be mixed at best. My advice is, try not to crash your car when you get out of bed on Monday morning because the clock says it’s six a.m. even thought your body knows that it’s only five.


In Other News:
The Simpsons are coming to the big screen and this time it’s for real.And, (Pope John) Paul (II) is still dead.

$7.50 for the Guy?


More than a dozen years ago a British friend of mine told me the story of Guy Fawkes. A revolutionary, idealist, demolitions enthusiast, and terrorist all rolled into one and canonized in England for the act of attempting to blow up Parliament. (Not to be confused with the act of offering George Clinton an eight-ball, this guy was actually carrying gunpowder with the intent to detonate it beneath the Houses of Parliament and assassinate King James I.)

The film, “V for Vendetta”, comes to us not only as a reminder of the value of well-intentioned protest (and yes, even a bit of terrorism,) but of the evils of sacrificing freedoms for the sake of ‘security’. It also strives to demonstrate just how difficult and costly it might be to regain those freedoms.

Set in a neither distant nor farfetched future, questionable wars (begun by the United States,) swarms of vice, and plagues of disease have destabilized the calm tea-times of the British soul. An opportunistic bureaucrat, played with venom and unblinking, vein-popping, precision by John Hurt (in a stroke of deeply ironic casting,) has risen to power on a platform of security that is supported by fear, hate, religious zealotry, media control and a healthy curfew. Unfortunately, for him (but most helpful to the plot of the film,) he’s made an enemy on the way up: a man known only as ‘V’. Inspired by the Count of Monte Christo and the notorious Guy Fawkes, ‘V’ rises from the darkness to rescue Natalie Portman and the British rabble from the grips of fear and tyranny (and bad television.)

A movie whose protagonist is a terrorist might seem inappropriate in these troubled times. But, those who see the film and give it the slightest bit of thought will recognize that it is posing an important question. Who is really engaging in terrorism: the government that distributes mis-information, acts against its citizens and controls them with an iron hand and the cold ropes of fear; or those who stand up and, through any means necessary, shine a revealing light into the dark, undisclosed locations where that government hides its most desperate secrets?

Rolling over and playing dead is a game for dogs. All Americans owe it to themselves to see this film.

“Hold on,” I hear you say, “all that high-minded, well-intentioned stuff is well and good but is the movie actually worth my cash?”

I’d have to say, “Yes.”

On all of the major points It makes a strong showing. Based on characters from a graphic novel (Don’t let that scare you off. This is no Sin City.), the screenplay was penned by The Matrix writers, directors, and brothers, Andy and Larry Wachowski. Yielding the director’s chair to James McTeigue (who has finally made the jump up to the center seat after more than a decade of assistant-directing such films as the Matrix trilogy, Star Wars Ep. II, and Street Fighter) the Brothers Wachowski (who also produced) might would be batting with a perfect record were it not for those Matrix sequels. The script is intelligent, entertaining and carries significant meat for the actors to get their teeth into.

Portman comes in looking sweet and goes out looking hardened in a role that nearly redeems her over-melodramatic Star Wars performances. BBC go-to-guy, Stephen Fry also turns in a terrific supporting performance which will probably go tragically unnoticed by all award-giving organizations. Let me be the first to note that this man does excellent work in his brief time on the screen. Also on screen and far easier to not notice is Hugo Weaving. Despite constant screen time, unless you read the credits, you might not realize that he is the man behind the mask as ‘V’. His performance is all in the speeches and physicality and he carries it off delightfully.

All of this is filtered through excellent cinematography by the late Adrian Biddle who passed just days before the film premiered. In a film class I took, many years ago, we were given the opportunity to watch a film by Antonioni entitled “Professione: reporter“. But we watched it without sound and were asked, at several points to describe what we believed to be happening in the film. Most in the class were not far from the mark. Naturally, the fine details were lost without dialog but this, we decided, was a hallmark of good film making. “V for Vendetta” is one that, I suspect, would pass this test.